Board Thread:Help!/@comment-25532829-20141013061632/@comment-5094027-20141014024806

Almighty Stick is not hardmode exclusive, just grab a water candle and park yourself somewhere you expect to meet a lot of Man Eaters. I've never had the Angry Trapper drop one myself, so it might be easier in easy mode.

Or, y'know, just reroll. If you're not experimenting with stat loadouts like yours truly, it's not too hard to max a character and give 'em an optimal stat spread in a few hours tops, especially if you use your original character as a Party member.